Chapter’s of London met on August 21, 2012 to do a vertical tasting on a cult wine, Nota Bene, from Black Hill’s Estate Winery in Oliver, BC. Below are the results. The wines were purchased as a box set for $320.00, vintages 2007, 2008, 2009 and 2010.
PRESENT: STEVE GUNNING – WJC, CLAIRE BOULLEY – WJC, TIM WHITE – WJC, SHEILA LAUZON – WJC, STEWART WOOD – WJC; LORI EDWARDS – PRODUCT CONSULTANT WITH LCBO; BRANT ALLAIN – AWO, GEORGE PICCIN –AWO
This evening was started with two welcoming wines, 2002 Sandhill, ONE, Small Lots Program and a 2002 Quail’s Gate, Fume Blanc. Both wines are from BC and were sound, bold and alive.
NOTA BENE WINES: The panel was to evaluate the wines and assign which Vintage order the wines were served. Wines were served blind and in this order 2009, 2010, 2007 and 2008. The marking system is out of 100. The scores include Bronze 70-79; Silver 80-89 and Gold is 90-100.
2009 - Over all comments: Rich garnet color, bold fruit flavors with oak characteristics. Full bodied with hints of chocolate, black pepper, coffee, tertiary notes and a velvety smooth lengthy finish. 14.1 % alcohol. Number of Persons with Correct Vintage: 2
SCORES: 85; 80; 88; 90; 91; 89; 92; 90 Average Score for WJC: 87% Over all scores: 88%
2010: Over All Comments: Deep red, purple and inky edges; integrated oak; ripe black fruit, rich cedar notes, full bodied, cassis and raspberry on the palate, smooth mature tannins with a lingering finish. 14.2% alcohol. Number of Persons with Correct Vintage: 1
SCORES: 92; 86; 85; 86; 90; 87; 88; 87 Average Score for WJC: 88% Over all Scores: 88%
2007: Over All Comments: Garnet core to clear ruby rim; fruit forward nose, tight herbs; savory background with mint; big tannic structure; flavors of black tea, soya, burned sugar; persistent fruit on the finish. 14. 7% alcohol. Number of Persons with Correct Vintage: 2
SCORES: 85; 90; 89; 93; 90; 90; 93; 84 Average Score for WJC: 89 Over All Scores: 89%
2008: Over All comments: Red, purple hues in the glass. Sophisticated nose with hints of pepper, coffee and chocolate; Rich full body, elegant, smooth tannins; well structured; long and persistent flavors. 14% alcohol. Number of Persons with Correct Vintage: 2
SCORES: 93; 90; 87; 90; 88; 87; 92; 95 Average Score for WJC: 90 Over All Scores: 90%
It was agreed that these wines should be tested again in five years. These wines were a pleasure.